- 20 Marks
Question
Mr. Kofi Opoku is the direct shareholder of Unique Farms Ghana Limited and Speed Transport Ghana Limited. Unique Farms is engaged in tree crop farming and the company harvested the tree crops for the first time in 2019. In April, 2020, he received a copy of the audited financial statements of the two companies.
An analysis of the audited financial statements of the companies revealed the Unique Farms Ghana Limited is more profitable of the two companies. Speed Transport Ghana Limited however requires a lot of money for its operating activities and it mostly resorts to borrowing from financial institutions to meet its expenditure requirements. The high borrowing costs was affecting the profitability of the company.
Mr. Opoku also noticed that tax exposure on his investments is not ideal. Mr. Kofi Opoku has been informed that you are an expert in strategic tax planning.
Required
You are required to help Mr. Kofi Opoku restructure his companies in a manner that would provide a cheaper financing option for Speed Transport Ghana Limited and reduce his overall tax exposure on the investments.
Answer
Restructuring Plan for Mr. Kofi Opoku’s Companies
Tax Analysis
- Unique Farms Ghana Limited: Engaged in tree crop farming, its chargeable income is taxed at 1% for 10 years from 2019 (first harvest year) per Paragraph 1(1), Sixth Schedule, Income Tax Act, 2015 (Act 896).
- Speed Transport Ghana Limited: No tax concessions, taxed at 25% on chargeable income.
- Dividends:
- Returns from both companies to Mr. Opoku are dividends (Section 133, Act 896).
- Dividends are not deductible for tax purposes (Section 130(4), Act 896).
- Dividends paid to Mr. Opoku are subject to 8% withholding tax (Section 115, First Schedule, Act 896).
- Inter-Company Dividend Exemption: Dividends paid by a resident company to another resident company are exempt from tax if the receiving company controls at least 25% of the voting power (Section 59(3), Act 896).
Restructuring Strategy
- Make Unique Farms a Subsidiary: Restructure so Speed Transport Ghana Limited becomes the direct shareholder of Unique Farms Ghana Limited.
- Benefit: Dividends paid by Unique Farms to Speed Transport would be tax-exempt, leveraging the 25% voting power exemption.
- Financing Advantage: Unique Farms’ after-tax profits (taxed at 1%) can be transferred as tax-exempt dividends to Speed Transport, providing a low-cost financing option compared to high-cost borrowing.
- Share Swap Arrangement:
- Mr. Opoku exchanges his shares in Unique Farms for additional shares in Speed Transport.
- This makes Speed Transport the direct shareholder and Mr. Opoku the indirect shareholder of Unique Farms.
- Tax Deferral: The share swap is a replacement of a realized asset under Section 46, Act 896, deferring tax on any gains from the disposal of Unique Farms shares.
Conclusion
This restructuring reduces Mr. Opoku’s tax exposure by leveraging tax-exempt inter-company dividends and provides Speed Transport with a cost-effective financing mechanism using Unique Farms’ profits.
- Topic: Tax Strategies for New Business Formation
- Series: AUGUST 2020
- Uploader: Samuel Duah