Dumbura Republic is reputed for its high population density and the consequent availability of cheap labour. Surprisingly, due to the high premium placed on qualitative education in science and technology-based disciplines, the country has an abundance of highly skilled workforce suited for manufacturing industries. Other features of Dumbura Republic include adequate, accessible and reliable social infrastructure such as electricity, potable water, road and rail network, and an effective security network. Besides, the country also has a variety of tax incentives designed to attract foreign investments. These positive features of the socio-economic environment in Dumbura have attracted a lot of foreign investors, including several computer and mobile phones hardware production companies.

Indeed, the socio-economic environment in Dumbura is very business-friendly. Hence, it is not surprising that a lot of foreign companies have located their industrial plants in the country. Effects of this development include increased employment opportunities, influx of people in search of employment from neighbouring countries, spiralling rent rates for all categories of accommodation, worsening environmental pollution, and a spiking population growth rate, which is beginning to take its toll on available social infrastructure. Besides, the hitherto peaceful country is beginning to experience an increased rate of crimes such as burglary, robbery, cyber theft and kidnap that target expatriates particularly. The local population is becoming increasingly hostile to the expatriates and workers from neighbouring countries, accusing them of denying the local population access to good job opportunities.

You have been employed as a consultant to a computer and mobile phone hardware company, Cells Incorporated, which is considering relocating its major manufacturing plant from an Asian country to Dumbura Republic. This is hoped to bring down the cost of production and provide a ready market for about 20% of its products.

Required:
With the aid of Johnson, Scholes, and Whittington’s position on strategic management, advise Cells Incorporated on the elements of strategic management that must be taken into consideration in deciding whether to relocate its manufacturing plants to Dumbura Republic. Ensure that you make adequate references to the scenario above as might be relevant.

Johnson, Scholes and Whittington identified three elements of strategic management that Cells Incorporated must consider in deciding whether to relocate to Dumbura. These are:

  1. Strategic position
  2. Strategic choices
  3. Strategy into action

Each of these will be examined in some detail.

(i) Strategic Position

This is arrived at through an analysis of the position of the company in its markets. It involves determining the ways a company performs or can perform better than its competitors and vice versa.

It also requires an understanding of the factors in the ‘business environment’ that affect the company, and how the company will be affected by changes that are likely to happen in the environment in the future. Could the company be affected by changes in technology, the state of the economy or new laws? Even more important, perhaps, will there be changes in what customers want to buy, because of changes in society or lifestyles? If so, how might this affect what the company produces and sells? Hence, Cells Incorporated needs to take into consideration the facts presented in respect of the socio-economic environment of Dumbura.

Based on Johnson, Scholes and Whittington’s suggestions, there are three aspects of strategic position that Cells Incorporated needs to consider:

  • The environment
  • Strategic capability of the entity
  • Expectations and purposes

Environment (Threats and Opportunities)

The business environment consists of the threats and opportunities that exist, and it is important for Cells Incorporated to assess their significance. Threats are occurrences in the environment that could adversely affect the ability of the entity to achieve its objectives. Opportunities, on the other hand, are factors that might be exploited, to improve the ability of the entity to achieve its objectives. Generally, both threats and opportunities are made up of variables outside of the firm’s control. The existing threats and opportunities in Dumbura that should be considered by Cells Incorporated include:

  • Spiking rents, environmental pollution, growing hostility and increasing crime rates in Dumbura; and
  • Availability of cheap labour, social infrastructure and tax incentives in Dumbura.

Strategic Capability of the Entity (Strengths and Weaknesses)

Cells Incorporated needs to assess its strategic capability to understand what it can achieve. This involves an analysis of its strengths and weaknesses. This includes:

  • Identification of what Cells Incorporated is good at doing and what can be done to improve on these; and
  • Identification of areas of deficiencies of Cells Incorporated where its rivals seem to be better and what can be done to improve in these areas of deficiencies.

Expectations and Purposes

An analysis of the strategic position of Cells Incorporated requires its management to take a decision on the purpose of the entity and its objectives. The purpose of Cells Incorporated includes the reduction of the cost of production and the exploitation of the local market. Cells Incorporated also expects to take full advantage of available social infrastructure in Dumbura, e.g., electricity, water, road and rail networks, etc.

(ii) Strategic Choices

This involves identifying different possible strategies that Cells Incorporated might adopt and making a choice of the preferred strategies from the different alternatives that are available. There are three levels involved in the process of identifying alternative strategies and making strategic choices:

  • Corporate level and international;
  • Business level strategies; and
  • Development directions and methods.

(iii) Strategy into Action

The third element in the Johnson, Scholes and Whittington model of strategic management is ‘strategy into action’. This means implementing the chosen strategies. There are three aspects to strategy implementation:

  • Organising
  • Enabling
  • Managing change