Gray, Owen, and Adams (1996) provided a framework for classifying different groups of people and their views of the relationship between business organizations and society.

Required:

a. State and explain SEVEN levels or positions on social responsibility by Gray, Owen, and Adams (1996). (15 Marks)
b. State Johnson and Scholes FOUR possible ethical stances for a business entity. (5 Marks)

a) Seven Levels of Social Responsibility by Gray, Owen, and Adams:

  1. Pristine Capitalists
    • Believe the sole responsibility of a company is to maximize shareholder wealth, with no obligation to society at large.
  2. Expedients
    • Recognize shareholder wealth maximization as the primary goal but accept minor social responsibilities if strategically beneficial.
  3. Proponents of the Social Contract
    • Believe companies exist at society’s will, holding a “social contract” to meet societal needs, such as adhering to environmental standards.
  4. Social Ecologists
    • Argue that companies are responsible for creating social and environmental issues and must actively contribute to solving them.
  5. Socialists
    • Advocate for a fundamental restructuring of asset ownership, challenging traditional power concentrations like large corporations.
  6. Radical Feminists
    • Suggest society is dominated by aggressive, masculine values, calling for compassionate, cooperative approaches in business.
  7. Deep Ecologists/Deep Greens
    • Believe all life forms hold equal rights, and human activity, including business, should prioritize environmental sustainability.

b) Johnson and Scholes’ Four Ethical Stances:

  1. Maximizing Short-term Shareholder Interests
    • Focused on immediate financial returns, often disregarding broader ethical concerns.
  2. Maximizing Long-term Shareholder Interests
    • Balances shareholder returns with sustainable practices to ensure continued profitability and stability.
  3. Multiple Stakeholder Obligations
    • Recognizes a duty to various stakeholders, balancing shareholder interests with those of employees, customers, and society.
  4. Being a Shaper of Society
    • Views the organization as a leader in promoting societal welfare, going beyond profit to shape social norms and valueshis structuring provides the full answer for Question 4 as required. Let me know if further questions need to be addressed.
online
Knowsia AI Assistant

Conversations

Knowsia AI Assistant