- 8 Marks
Question
In response to some taxpayers’ behaviour, transfer pricing regulation has been passed to ensure that all arrangements are conducted at arm’s length. The Commissioner-General in his dealings with taxpayers must ensure that market price drives business transactions. The Commissioner-General reserves the right to allege abuse of transfer pricing if certain factors point to the fact that there is an arrangement not in accord with the dictate of market forces.
Required:
Explain FOUR (4) factors the Commissioner-General will rely on in his comparability analysis in Transfer Pricing arrangements.
Answer
The Commissioner-General relies on the following key factors when conducting a comparability analysis to ensure that transfer pricing arrangements adhere to the arm’s length principle:
- Characteristics of Properties or Services:
Differences in specific characteristics of property or services often account for differences in their value in the open market. Comparisons of these specific features might be useful in determining whether controlled transactions and uncontrolled transactions are comparable. Specific characteristics considered include quality, durability, and availability. - FAR Analysis (Function, Assets, and Risks):
The Commissioner-General will examine the functions performed, assets utilized, and risks assumed by each party in the transaction. Differences in the extent of functions performed or risks assumed by each party in a controlled relationship versus an uncontrolled relationship should be considered. Functions such as research, development, and marketing may influence the pricing. - Contractual Terms:
The contractual terms between related parties are examined to ensure they reflect true economic substance. Contractual terms may define the division of responsibilities, risks, and benefits. Any differences between controlled and uncontrolled terms need to be adjusted to reflect market conditions. - Economic Circumstances:
The economic conditions surrounding the transaction can affect its comparability. Differences in geographic location, market size, competition, and consumer purchasing power may explain variations in pricing. Factors such as market conditions at the time of the transaction and cost of production will also be considered. - Market penetration:
Multinational enterprises’ business strategies could include market penetration
strategies. Taxpayer seeking to penetrate a market or to measure its market share
might temporarily charge a price for the product that is lower than the same price
charged for otherwise comparable products in the same market.
Additionally, a taxpayer seeking to enter a new market or a taxpayer seeking to
expand or defend its market share might temporarily incur higher cost. Such costs
could include start-up costs or increased marketing efforts.
As a result, such a taxpayer might achieve lower profit levels than other taxpayers
operating in the same market or may even make losses at the market penetration
stage
- Tags: Arm's Length Principle, Comparability Analysis, Transfer Pricing
- Level: Level 3
- Topic: Anti-avoidance measures
- Series: APR 2022
- Uploader: Kwame Aikins