- 10 Marks
Question
On 1 January 2023, Fabin Ghana Airlines PLC (FGA) leased a new fuel-efficient aircraft from German Jets Builders PLC (GJB) for ten (10) years, with an option to extend the lease period for five (5) additional years. However, at lease inception, FGA determined that the renewal option was not economically beneficial and would not be exercised.
The lease formed part of FGA’s sustainability strategy to green its air operations. Lease payments were structured as follows:
- Fixed annual lease payments of €6 million, payable at each year-end starting 31 December 2023.
- An additional 5% annual payment, conditional on FGA’s aircraft noise footprints and nitrogen oxide emissions declining by at least 15% and 10%, respectively.
- At 31 December 2023, the Sustainability Committee determined that these environmental targets were met.
Additional lease details:
- Estimated residual value of €15 million at 31 December 2032 and €10 million at 31 December 2037.
- Residual Value Guarantee: FGA guaranteed that the relevant residual value will not drop below 30%.
- Initial Direct Costs: GH¢500,000 was incurred in setting up the lease.
- Discount Rate: 12%
- Exchange Rates:
- 1 January 2023: €1 = GH¢10
- 31 December 2023: €1 = GH¢12
- Average rate: €1 = GH¢11
Discount Factors at 12%:
Year | Single-Period Factor | Annuity Factor |
---|---|---|
10 | 0.32 | 5.65 |
14 | 0.20 | 6.63 |
15 | 0.18 | 6.81 |
Required:
In line with IFRS 16: Leases and IAS 21: Effects of Changes in Foreign Exchange Rates, discuss how this lease should be accounted for in the financial statements of FGA for the year ended 31 December 2023.
Answer
Lease Accounting Under IFRS 16
IFRS 16 requires lessees to recognize:
- A right-of-use asset at cost, which includes initial direct costs and lease liability.
- A lease liability at the present value of future lease payments, discounted using the incremental borrowing rate (12%).
The right-of-use asset is subsequently depreciated over the lease term. The lease liability is adjusted for finance costs, lease payments, and remeasurements due to changes in discount rate or foreign exchange rates.
(i) Initial Recognition of Lease Liability
The lease liability is measured at the present value of future lease payments as follows:
Calculation of Lease Liability (At Initial Recognition in Euros)
Lease Liability=(Fixed Payments×Annuity Factor)+(Residual Value Guarantee×Single-Period Factor)\text{Lease Liability} = (\text{Fixed Payments} \times \text{Annuity Factor}) + (\text{Residual Value Guarantee} \times \text{Single-Period Factor})Lease Liability=(Fixed Payments×Annuity Factor)+(Residual Value Guarantee×Single-Period Factor) =(€6M×5.65)+(€15M×30%×0.32)= (€6M \times 5.65) + (€15M \times 30\% \times 0.32)=(€6M×5.65)+(€15M×30%×0.32) =€33.9M+€1.44M= €33.9M + €1.44M=€33.9M+€1.44M =€35.34M= €35.34M=€35.34M
Translation at 1 January 2023 (Initial Recognition in Ghana Cedis):
€35.34M×10=GH¢353.4M€35.34M \times 10 = GH¢353.4M€35.34M×10=GH¢353.4M
(ii) Lease Liability Subsequent Measurement at 31 December 2023
Year | Lease Liability (€’000) | Interest (12%) (€’000) | Lease Payment (€’000) | Closing Balance (€’000) |
---|---|---|---|---|
2023 | 35,340 | 4,241 | (6,000) | 33,581 |
2024 | 33,581 | 4,030 | (6,000) | 31,611 |
Translation of Lease Liability at 31 December 2023:
Closing Lease Liability=€33.581M×12=GH¢402.972M\text{Closing Lease Liability} = €33.581M \times 12 = GH¢402.972MClosing Lease Liability=€33.581M×12=GH¢402.972M
Exchange Loss:
Exchange Loss=(Closing Lease Liability−Opening Lease Liability)=(GH¢402.972M−GH¢353.4M)=GH¢49.572M\text{Exchange Loss} = (\text{Closing Lease Liability} – \text{Opening Lease Liability}) = (GH¢402.972M – GH¢353.4M) = GH¢49.572MExchange Loss=(Closing Lease Liability−Opening Lease Liability)=(GH¢402.972M−GH¢353.4M)=GH¢49.572M
(iii) Right-of-Use Asset Measurement
ROU Asset=Initial Lease Liability+Initial Direct Costs\text{ROU Asset} = \text{Initial Lease Liability} + \text{Initial Direct Costs}ROU Asset=Initial Lease Liability+Initial Direct Costs =GH¢353.4M+GH¢0.5M=GH¢353.9M= GH¢353.4M + GH¢0.5M = GH¢353.9M=GH¢353.4M+GH¢0.5M=GH¢353.9M
Depreciation Charge (Straight-Line Over 10 Years):
GH¢353.9M10=GH¢35.39M\frac{GH¢353.9M}{10} = GH¢35.39M10GH¢353.9M=GH¢35.39M
(iv) Additional Lease Payment (Variable Payment at Year-End)
Since environmental conditions were met, an additional lease payment of 5% (€6M) was due.
Variable Lease Payment=5%×€6M=€0.3M\text{Variable Lease Payment} = 5\% \times €6M = €0.3MVariable Lease Payment=5%×€6M=€0.3M Translation at Average Rate=€0.3M×11=GH¢3.3M\text{Translation at Average Rate} = €0.3M \times 11 = GH¢3.3MTranslation at Average Rate=€0.3M×11=GH¢3.3M
This variable lease payment is expensed, as it is not included in the initial lease liability.
(v) Journal Entries for 31 December 2023
Initial Lease Recognition (1 January 2023)
- Dr Right-of-Use Asset GH¢353.9M
- Cr Lease Liability GH¢353.4M
- Cr Bank (Initial Direct Costs) GH¢0.5M
Depreciation Charge (31 December 2023)
- Dr Depreciation Expense GH¢35.39M
- Cr Accumulated Depreciation GH¢35.39M
Lease Payment (31 December 2023)
- Dr Lease Liability GH¢72M (€6M * 12)
- Cr Bank GH¢72M
Finance Cost (Interest on Lease)
- Dr Interest Expense GH¢46.65M (€4.241M * 11)
- Cr Lease Liability GH¢46.65M
Exchange Loss Adjustment
- Dr Exchange Loss (P&L) GH¢49.57M
- Cr Lease Liability GH¢49.57M
Variable Lease Payment
- Dr Lease Expense GH¢3.3M
- Cr Bank GH¢3.3M
Financial Statement Extracts
Statement of Financial Position (31 December 2023)
Assets | GH¢’000 |
---|---|
Right-of-Use Asset | 318,510 |
Liabilities | GH¢’000 |
---|---|
Lease Liability (Non-Current) | 379,332 |
Lease Liability (Current) | 23,640 |
Conclusion
The lease is recognized as a right-of-use asset and lease liability, with exchange losses and variable lease payments expensed.
- Topic: Effects of Changes in Foreign Exchange Rates, IFRS 16: Leases
- Series: Nov 2024
- Uploader: Salamat Hamid