AAA – L3 – Q55 – Reporting

55 Richmond Computers

Richmond Computers sells personal computers (PCs) to independent shops. You are the external auditor of Richmond Computers. Your interim audit revealed the following issues:

(1) The half year physical inventory count revealed that some PCs supposed to be in inventory were missing and that other machines which had been returned by customers were in inventory but had not been recorded as having been returned. A few of the missing PCs have been traced to directors who borrowed them for use at home.

(2) Two customers had been allowed to exceed their credit limits and new customers in the last year had not been allocated credit limits.

Required

Draft the section of your report to management dealing with the above deficiencies in internal control. Set out the deficiencies, their implications and your recommendations for improvement.

(1) Inventory records and PCs held by directors
Deficiencies
The inventory records are not a reliable record of actual inventory held because:

  • customer returns have not been recorded
  • some items recorded as being in inventory are missing
  • Some ‘missing’ items are held at directors’ own homes.
    Implications
  • Year-end inventories may be misstated if reliance is placed on year-end inventory records instead of a year-end count.
  • Inventory losses may go unnoticed until the next physical count delaying insurance claims and making theft more likely.
  • Customers may not be given credit for goods returned such that trade receivables will be overstated and there may be a loss of customer goodwill.
  • PCs ‘borrowed’ by the directors are unlikely to still be suitable for resale at their full value and may need to be written down in the financial statements.
  • Orders could be accepted which cannot be fulfilled if decisions are taken based on incorrect inventory records.
    Recommendations
  • All inventory despatches should be recorded on sequentially numbered despatch notes.
  • Customer returns should be recorded on sequentially numbered returns notes and matched to the original despatch note.
  • Physical inventory counts should be conducted at least quarterly, with discrepancies investigated and resolved promptly.
  • A policy should be implemented prohibiting directors from borrowing company assets for personal use, and any existing borrowed items should be returned and inspected for resale suitability.
  • Inventory records should be reconciled regularly with physical counts, and any discrepancies should be investigated and corrected.

(2) Credit limits
Deficiencies

  • Two customers have been allowed to exceed their credit limits.
  • New customers in the last year have not been allocated credit limits.
    Implications
  • Allowing customers to exceed credit limits increases the risk of bad debts, which could lead to financial losses.
  • Failure to allocate credit limits to new customers means there is no control over the credit extended, increasing the risk of uncollectible receivables.
  • Poor credit control may damage relationships with suppliers or financiers if cash flow is impacted by uncollected debts.
    Recommendations
  • Implement a formal credit control policy requiring credit checks and approval before sales are made to new customers.
  • Assign credit limits to all customers based on their creditworthiness and review these limits regularly.
  • Install system controls to prevent sales to customers who have exceeded their credit limits without senior management approval.
  • Regularly review aged debtor reports and follow up promptly on overdue accounts to minimize bad debt risk.