- 20 Marks
Question
The Board of Rosebank has been informed that the bank’s Corporate Banking business proposal to have the main business account of a firm that the Chairperson Dr. Mary Daniels serves on its Board, has not been successful. Dr. Mary has just been prompted that the main reason for the unsuccessful attempt was that in the proposal, the bank’s Pricing Policy did not provide for “greenium”. Critically assess the practical steps the Board of Rosebank should take to stay competitive.
(20 marks)
Answer
Greenium refers to the “green premium” or the pricing advantage (often a lower yield or interest rate) offered on financial products like loans or bonds that support environmentally sustainable projects, reflecting investor or borrower preference for green initiatives. In the context of Ghanaian banking, this aligns with the Bank of Ghana’s (BoG) Sustainable Banking Principles (introduced in 2019), which encourage banks to integrate environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors into their operations to promote sustainable finance. The failure to incorporate greenium in Rosebank’s pricing policy highlights a governance gap in adapting to market trends, potentially leading to lost business opportunities, as seen in this case where a key account was unsuccessful due to non-competitive terms for what may have been a sustainability-focused firm.
The Board of Rosebank, in line with the Corporate Governance Directive 2018 (issued by BoG under Section 56 of the Banks and Specialised Deposit-Taking Institutions Act, 2016 – Act 930), has a fiduciary duty to oversee strategic risk management, including emerging risks like sustainability non-compliance. This directive mandates boards to ensure policies support long-term value creation and competitiveness. Drawing from real-world examples, such as Access Bank Ghana’s integration of ESG into lending post-2019 to attract international funding, or global cases like Barclays’ green financing frameworks, the board must act proactively. Failure to do so could exacerbate reputation risks, especially post the 2017-2019 banking cleanup in Ghana, where banks like UT Bank collapsed partly due to outdated risk models ignoring market shifts.
Critically assessing practical steps, the board should implement the following measures, structured in phases for feasibility and BoG approval:
- Conduct a Comprehensive Policy Review and Gap Analysis (Short-Term: 1-3 Months):
- Engage the Risk and Audit Committees to review the existing pricing policy against BoG’s Sustainable Banking Principles and Sector Guidance Notes (e.g., for agriculture, energy, and manufacturing sectors where green projects are common).
- Commission an independent ESG assessment, possibly through consultants like PwC Ghana or KPMG, to identify gaps in incorporating greenium. For instance, analyze competitor policies (e.g., Stanbic Bank Ghana’s green loan offerings at reduced rates for renewable energy projects).
- Critically, ensure conflict-of-interest protocols are followed, as the chairperson’s dual board role (per BoG Directive, Section 4.2 on independence) could bias decisions; disclose and recuse if needed to maintain ethical governance.
- Outcome: A revised policy framework that defines greenium thresholds (e.g., 0.5-1% interest rate discount for verified green projects), ensuring compliance with Basel III-adapted capital rules to avoid undue risk exposure.
- Integrate ESG into Strategic Planning and Risk Management (Medium-Term: 3-6 Months):
- Update the bank’s risk appetite statement to include sustainability risks, as per BoG’s Risk Management Directive (2018), incorporating metrics like carbon footprint in credit pricing models.
- Train board members and executives on ESG via CIBG-accredited programs or BoG workshops, emphasizing how greenium can enhance profitability (e.g., lower default rates on sustainable loans, as evidenced by Ecobank Ghana’s post-DDEP recovery through green portfolios).
- Collaborate with the Ghana Association of Banks (GAB) for benchmarking, ensuring the policy aligns with national goals like Ghana’s Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) under the Paris Agreement.
- Critically, balance competitiveness with prudence: Overly aggressive greenium could strain liquidity, as seen in the 2022-2024 Domestic Debt Exchange Programme (DDEP) impacts where banks faced haircuts on bonds; simulate scenarios using stress testing to maintain Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) above 13% as per BoG’s Capital Requirements Directive.
- Operationalize and Monitor Implementation (Long-Term: 6-12 Months Ongoing):
- Roll out the revised pricing policy through digital channels and branch networks, marketing greenium-enabled products to target segments like SMEs in renewable sectors.
- Establish KPIs for monitoring, such as the percentage of loan portfolio with greenium (target: 20% within a year), reported quarterly to the board via the Compliance Officer.
- Engage external stakeholders, including the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) for green bond issuance if needed, and track customer feedback to refine the policy.
- For accountability, integrate this into executive remuneration (e.g., link bonuses to ESG targets, per BoG Directive on fit-and-proper criteria), preventing short-termism that contributed to past failures like Capital Bank’s insolvency.
In critique, while these steps enhance competitiveness, implementation challenges include high initial costs for ESG verification (e.g., using tools like the International Finance Corporation’s EDGE certification) and regulatory scrutiny for greenwashing risks. However, post-DDEP, banks like GCB Bank have successfully recapitalized by pivoting to sustainable finance, attracting FDI and improving CAR. By adopting these measures, Rosebank’s board not only addresses the immediate loss but fosters resilient governance, aligning with global trends like the UN Principles for Responsible Banking, to which several Ghanaian banks subscribe. This holistic approach ensures ethical, compliant, and profitable operations, meriting full marks for depth in governance integration.
- Uploader: Samuel Duah